Iraq and Syria are lost causes: western intervention can't help
BY spectator events
October 22, 2014
Church House, Dean's Yard, London SW1P 3NZ
Andrew Neil, chairman, The Spectator Magazine Group
John Redwood MP, For the motion, chair, Economic Affairs Committee
Patrick Cockburn, For the motion, correspondent, The Independent
Nabila Ramdani, For the motion, French-Algerian journalist, and broadcaster specialising in Islamic affairs, and the Arab World
Barack Obama says that the so-called Islamic State is a ‘cancer’. He may have started air strikes but he still doesn’t have a clear plan. Having bungled our last invasion of Iraq, many argue that America and Britain have a moral duty to save the region from the religious fanatics now taking over. Since hundreds of British jihadists are now fighting for the new caliphate, the success of Isis presents a domestic terror threat, too. But do America and its allies have the political will or money for another war? Or has the cancer grown so large that now nobody can cut it out?
Attendees had been asked about their voting intention as they arrived; the answer was for the motion, 83; against, 64; undecided, 139. After the debate, the tables had turned: for, 123; against, 216, and undecided, 24, meaning that the motion was defeated.